Charlet Sanieoff on Buy Now, Pay Later This Holiday Season: What's Changed in 2026 and How to Avoid a January Debt Hangover

Charlet Sanieoff (co) • November 17, 2026

The holidays are supposed to feel exciting, not financially terrifying. But as Black Friday and Cyber Monday arrive, millions of Americans are reaching for a checkout option that feels effortless in the moment and complicated in January. Buy Now, Pay Later - commonly called BNPL - has quietly become one of the most widely used financial tools in holiday shopping, and this year, Charlet Sanieoff is sounding a timely alarm. The numbers behind BNPL in 2026 are bigger than ever, but so are the signs of strain. If you are planning to split any purchases into installments this season, there are things you need to know before you click "confirm."

Charlet Sanieoff has been watching the BNPL landscape shift in ways that matter deeply for everyday shoppers. This post lays out what is new in 2026, why late payments are climbing, what is happening with credit scores, and - most importantly - how to come out of the holiday season without a debt hangover that follows you into the new year.

The Holiday BNPL Boom Is Bigger Than You Think

To understand why Charlet Sanieoff is raising these concerns right now, start with the scale of what is happening. Adobe forecasts that Buy Now, Pay Later will drive more than $21 billion in holiday spending this season, representing a 6.6 percent increase from last year. That figure sits inside a record $275.1 billion in total U.S. online sales projected between November 1 and December 31, 2026 - itself a 6.7 percent year-over-year increase. BNPL now accounts for approximately 8 percent of all holiday online spending, and Adobe describes it as a standard checkout option rather than a niche alternative.

What is especially notable is how shoppers are using it. It is not just big-ticket gifts or electronics. Adobe reports that many consumers are using BNPL to take advantage of seasonal discounts to stock up on everyday essentials. That detail matters, and Charlet Sanieoff will return to it shortly. Meanwhile, LendingTree's October 2026 tracker found that 43 percent of Americans are at least considering a BNPL loan this month. That is up 3 points from September, though still below the record 48 percent recorded in December 2025. Demand is high, momentum is building, and the holiday season is just getting started.

When something becomes this normalized, it is easy to stop thinking critically about it. That is precisely when caution matters most.

Charlet Sanieoff on the Real Strain Behind the Sales Numbers

Here is what the checkout screens do not show you. According to LendingTree survey data from March 2026, 47 percent of BNPL users paid late at least once in the past year. That is up from 41 percent in 2025 and 34 percent in 2024. The trend is moving in the wrong direction, and it is moving fast. Charlet Sanieoff wants readers to sit with that number for a moment - nearly half of all people using these plans have already slipped up on a payment.

The good news, if there is any, is that most late payments are brief. Among those who paid late, 72 percent say their most recent late payment was no more than about a week overdue. That suggests many people are not in deep financial distress - they are simply losing track. Due dates creep up, paychecks land on the wrong day, and suddenly a "free" installment plan is generating a late fee.

But the data points beyond simple forgetfulness. Consider these findings from the same LendingTree research:

  • 25 percent of BNPL users have had three or more BNPL loans active at the same time, and 63 percent have held multiple loans simultaneously. This is called "stacking," and it is one of the most common ways small, manageable payments quietly pile up into something unmanageable.
  • 29 percent of BNPL users have used these loans to buy groceries, up from 25 percent a year earlier and just 14 percent two years ago. Among Gen Z users, the rate climbs to 38 percent.
  • 54 percent of BNPL users say they would not be able to make ends meet without access to these loans.
  • 54 percent of BNPL users have regretted a BNPL purchase, up from 48 percent in 2025.

Charlet Sanieoff notes that these are not abstract statistics. When more than half of users express regret and dependency in the same survey, that is a signal worth taking seriously. CFPB research reinforces the concern, showing that BNPL borrowers are significantly more likely than non-users to carry revolving credit card balances and to rely on overdraft, payday, and pawn loans. And a College Investor survey found that 38 percent of holiday shoppers are still paying off something they purchased last holiday season - including 21 percent still making BNPL payments from last year's gifts.

What Is Genuinely New in 2026 - and Why It Changes the Calculation

Even if you have used BNPL before without major problems, 2026 has introduced some developments that change the stakes. Charlet Sanieoff believes these updates deserve more attention than they are currently getting from mainstream financial coverage.

The most significant shift is that BNPL is beginning to appear in credit scores. FICO launched new scoring models - FICO Score 10 BNPL and FICO Score 10 T BNPL - designed to incorporate buy now, pay later data. Affirm now reports loans directly to Experian and TransUnion. The practical impact is still limited because most lenders continue to use older scoring models that do not yet include BNPL data, and payment experts suggest it could take years before widespread lender adoption occurs. But the direction of travel is clear. If you pay on time, it may start helping your score. If you miss payments, it may start hurting it. The specific impact depends on which BNPL provider you use and whether they report to the bureaus.

This matters enormously if you are planning to apply for a mortgage or car loan in 2027. Charlet Sanieoff strongly recommends checking your provider's reporting policy before you open a new plan this season.

Lenders are also seeing more delinquency at the institutional level. Affirm reported that 30-plus day late loans rose 35 basis points sequentially to 2.9 percent, even as its gross merchandise volume climbed 34 percent to $14.4 billion. Block, the parent company of Afterpay, reported consumer lending originations reaching $19.0 billion, up 40 percent year over year. Volume is surging and so is the late-payment rate.

On the regulatory front, the CFPB issued a rule in 2024 that treated some BNPL products similarly to credit cards, but that rule was withdrawn in May 2025. States are stepping in to fill the gap. New York proposed expansive new BNPL regulations on February 23, 2026, implementing the Buy-Now-Pay-Later Act. Under the proposal, BNPL loans that charge interest would be subject to a 16 percent interest-rate cap. Those rules will take effect 180 days after a final rule is adopted - but they are not yet in force, and most of the country is not covered.

Finally, borrowing costs remain elevated. The Federal Reserve left its target federal funds rate at 3.75 to 4.00 percent at its October 28 meeting. The average APR for new credit card offers reached 23.96 percent in October. Why does that matter for BNPL? Because if you miss a payment and cover it with a credit card, or if you pay off a BNPL balance using your card, that "interest-free" purchase is no longer interest-free. It is now costing nearly 24 percent annually.

Charlet Sanieoff's 7 Rules for Using BNPL Wisely This Holiday Season

None of this means you should never use Buy Now, Pay Later. It means you should use it strategically. Charlet Sanieoff has put together seven practical rules to help you shop this season without setting yourself up for a painful January.

  • Apply the two-paycheck test. If the full price of an item would not fit comfortably within your next two paychecks, do not split the purchase into installments. The plan makes it feel affordable, but your underlying budget has not changed.
  • Limit yourself to one active plan at a time. A quarter of BNPL users have stacked three or more loans simultaneously. This is how manageable-sounding payments combine into a missed one. Keep it simple and keep it singular.
  • Do not use pay-in-4 for groceries or everyday essentials. If you are splitting grocery bills into installments, that is a budget warning sign that needs to be addressed directly, not deferred. Charlet Sanieoff urges readers to treat this pattern as a prompt to revisit their monthly spending plan.
  • Turn on autopay and align due dates with your payday. Most late payments are just a few days overdue, which suggests people are losing track rather than running out of money. Automation solves this. Many BNPL providers allow you to shift your payment date - call and ask.
  • Ask for a late fee waiver if you slip. LendingTree data shows that 90 percent of people who asked to have a late fee waived got it reduced or eliminated entirely. It costs nothing to ask and could save you real money.
  • Know your provider's credit reporting policy before you buy. Some BNPL plans now affect your credit file. If you are planning a major loan application in 2027, check how your provider handles reporting. Missed payments on a newly reportable account could affect your mortgage rate or car loan approval.
  • Pay off last year's debt before adding new debt. If you are still making payments on something you bought last December, focus there first. Then consider building a small holiday sinking fund - even setting aside a modest amount each month through the year makes the next holiday season far less stressful.

These rules are not about restriction. They are about giving yourself a holiday season that feels genuinely good rather than one that generates regret and stress well into 2027.

The Bigger Picture Charlet Sanieoff Wants You to Carry Into the New Year

Charlet Sanieoff believes that financial tools are only as good as the awareness that surrounds their use. Buy Now, Pay Later is not inherently dangerous. Used thoughtfully - for a planned, budgeted purchase with a single active plan and autopay turned on - it can be a reasonable way to manage cash flow through a high-spending season. The danger lies in how normalized it has become, how effortless the checkout experience feels, and how easy it is to open three or four plans simultaneously without fully registering what you have committed to.

The 2026 data tells a story of a tool that has grown faster than many users' ability to manage it. Late payments are rising every year. Regret is rising every year. Dependency is rising every year. And now, for the first time, some of these loans are beginning to follow you into your credit history. That is a meaningful shift.

At the same time, 38 percent of Americans are still paying off last year's holiday spending as this year's Black Friday arrives. If you are in that group, you are not alone - but you are also in the best position to understand why adding more installment debt right now deserves careful thought.

The goal of this post is not to make the holidays feel grim. It is to help you celebrate generously and thoughtfully, with eyes open to what the checkout screen does not tell you. Charlet Sanieoff's core message this season is straightforward: the best gift you can give yourself and your family is a January that starts without financial regret. Plan accordingly, use the rules above, and enjoy the season from a position of real confidence rather than deferred anxiety.

If you found this post helpful, share it with someone who is about to start their holiday shopping. The more people who go into this season with accurate information, the better the new year looks for everyone. And if you have questions about managing your finances through the holidays and beyond, stay connected with Charlet Sanieoff for practical guidance you can actually use.

More design inspirations